Total Pageviews

Saturday, April 23, 2011

The Somme Still Flows by Edmund Blunden - A Reflection

War. What is war? When two or more countries face off each other in the battlefield with weapons, indulge in bloodshed and at some point in time announce permanent cease-fire? Then arises a critical question - who won? Can this question ever be answered? Yes, those blinded by the lust for power will claim they have emerged victorious. A case in point, the U.S. success in Afghanistan and Iraq. Success. Victory. What are they? How do you measure success? Edmund Blunden shows us the real face of war in his essay. He writes as the one who has seen the reality of war. Blunden opines in his essay that neither of the two sides is a winner in a war. There is one winner, and that is War itself. It is easy to start a war, but hardly ever an end to a war can be seen or is achieved. The battle of the Somme started on July 1st, 1916. The British had surprises for the French in the form of jumping-off positions, field guns to be fired from the front trenches. But so had the French. Battalions disappeared. It is hard to imagine the presence of hope in a field where bodies are falling to the right and left of you.  But it was there. Hope to remain alive at the end of a day, and hoping to survive the next day - it was an eternal circle of hope. "The heart of the monster lay South", and so Blunden and his fellow troops entered it. This is when the nightmarish quality of War showed its head. This is where the significance of this essay comes in. The writer successfully breaks the false aura of glory woven around war, and paints its true ugly colours.  The colourful Summer painted the writer and his mates' world grey by bringing death and hopelessness. The smell of gunpowder replaced the fragrance of flowers, the chirping birds took the form of roaring guns. The youthful troops who had entered the battlefield bursting with enthusiasm, returned in odd numbers with the image of death ingrained in their minds forever. As the winter took its roots, the writer and his fellow troops left the battlefield - the season a fitting compliment to the young men who were merely ghosts of themselves. The writer then tries to explain what war really is. He says there are no cornfields, no glory. Only the silent grave waiting to swallow you in a sombre cemetery. War is a Monster which swallows one up. Even if it spews out few, they are permanently covered by its slime. It takes nothing away from those who died fighting for their country though - the only people who can upstage them are those who prick out the thorn called war.
What touches the reader in this essay are the words used by the writer, each dripping with feeling and stamped by suffering. The readers can actually see the life being sucked out of a brimming young man, leaving him as a ghost of his former self. The world hasn't become war-free. Cities are still being wiped out, youth is still being drawn into the falsehood of war. Only it has become deadlier. The nuclear war has wiped out the concept of bodies, graves and cemeteries. The writer expresses hope in the title of the story. "The Somme Still Flows." Is there hope in today's world? Is there going to be a favourable result of the Palestine struggle? Can anyone see a prosperous Afghanistan? Can anyone see a progressive Iraq? Is peace ever going to reign in Pakistan? Edmund Blunden concludes with the philosophical thought that life goes on and nature continues to bloom. Yes, life goes on; hope springs eternal;  but solution to today's problems.....??

7 comments:

  1. Salam.
    Can you please post a reflection on essay "Refuge from nightmare" by Gerald Gould and "The golden drugget" by Hilarie Belloc

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ESSAY: 03
      THE GOLDEN DRUGGET
      By: Sir Max Beerbohm
      The golden grugget is composed by Sir Max Beerbohm and is extracted from “from and even now”. It is a descriptive essay in which the author shares his experience which made him happy. Beerbohm states that human desire is naturally based upon primitive nature which appeals to us. In his view old things are more attractive than the new things for example a mother who is holding a baby in a picture is more attractive than a woman attending a board meeting in a picture. Scientific progress and modern machines and technology snatch the beauty from the nature. To present his idea he opens his essay as;
      “Primitive and essential have great power to touch the heart of beholder.”
      The author gives another example to clarify his idea that a picture of a girl who is filling water from the tap will not be as much attractive as a picture of man flowing in the fields. In the author’s view natural things serve as the best topic for the poetry and modern poetry is not attractive as the old poetry because it is emotionless.
      The author paves way to describe his own imaginary particular Inn from where a yellow beam of light comes out; it was actually golden drugget for him. It was not noticed in the day light but at night it had a magical effect. He adds description of the Inn that it was a lonely and abundant and beam of light which came out of it was warm and welcoming in the thick dark of nights. The author says that in the environment of great fear of robbers and suspicious feelings the beam of light brought the thoughts of peace, joy and hope to our hearts. The effect of this beam of light was more than the effect of lights emitting from five star hotels in London. He compares the golden drugget to life. He says that life is nothing but a golden drugget. Before coming into this world we were in dark than we came to life or the golden drugget and after this darkness will come which means death. The author has a philosophical view of the golden drugget. The author says that the golden drugget is between the two darkness.

      Delete
    2. Thankyou so much...I can't tell you how much you have helped me

      Delete
    3. Can you plz help me with the other essay refuge from nightmare too?

      Delete
  2. Your reviews are helpful. Can u plz post the Refuge from nightmare and beauty and the beast!!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. pls also essay quality by john galsworthy

    ReplyDelete
  4. What were the experiences of edmund blunder in the world war 1 as described in the somme still flows?

    ReplyDelete